AJ`s Pizza in Bayfield

Rip off! I paid $38 for essentially 2 medium sized CHEESE PIZZAS. I was trying to feed a group of movers and they barely fed 6 people. When they rang me up I was in shock, but I thought based on the price I'd have 2 very large pizzas. They weren't any bigger than a frozen pizza! I could've had 5 frozen pizzas WITH TOPPINGS for the same price and they would've tasted like something. I've had better cheaper pizza at Chuck E. Cheese. Very disappointing. We won't be going back.

Always good food and kind employees.

Pizza crust is to thin & pizza is greasy. Bread sticks had lil flavor. Wings are the only way to go

Friendly staff and quick service!

Great pizza, a little greasy, but amaz9ng crust reminiscent of pizza places from my childhood! Will go again.

Stopped in for lunch as I travel all over for work and was not disappointed. Had the deluxe special for lunch and the lady made it fresh and fast. I didn't catch her name, but I suspect she was the owner and SUPER nice. Will definitely be back next time I'm in Bayfield!

One of the best pizzas I had.

Best pizza in Bayfield

Great pizza with great customer service. Support your local pizza shop! I’ve loved this place since I was a kid and it’s still got it.